Rushville Collection / Historical Essay

Rushville and the Underground Railroad

How Rushville became part of the struggle over slavery, and how Benjamin Hanby gave that history a voice.

A village in a wider history

From Rushville to the nation

A song heard across nineteenth-century America leads back to the small Ohio village of Rushville. Benjamin Russell Hanby (1833–1867) was born here, and the village’s antislavery history became inseparable from the story of his most famous ballad.

Born in Rushville, Hanby grew up in a household deeply involved in antislavery activism. His father, the United Brethren minister William Hanby, later a bishop, helped people escaping enslavement; the family’s homes in Rushville and Westerville are remembered as Underground Railroad stations. The family’s abolitionist convictions also shaped Benjamin’s work as a composer. The United Methodist Church’s historical archives document the Hanbys’ involvement in both communities.

In 1856, Hanby published Darling Nelly Gray, an antislavery song that reached audiences across the United States in the tense years before the Civil War. Its story of separation, loss, and the denial of freedom was rooted in memories of the people who sought refuge along the Underground Railroad.

Tabletop display of Rushville historical books, photographs and documents, with an early Darling Nelly Gray sheet music cover prominently in the foreground
A selection of materials from the privately held Rushville Collection, including historic photographs, local-history sources, and printed music associated with Darling Nelly Gray.
People and places

The Underground Railroad in Rushville

Before the Civil War, networks of free Black and white abolitionists, churches, families, and sympathetic neighbors helped freedom seekers travel through Ohio toward places of greater safety. The routes were neither literal railroads nor a single coordinated organization. They depended upon private homes, local knowledge, personal courage, and considerable risk, particularly under the federal Fugitive Slave Act of 1850.

Rushville became part of that wider movement. Local historical accounts identify both William Hanby and Dr. Simon Hyde among residents who assisted freedom seekers. Hyde is remembered for providing medical care as well as shelter. The historic Hyde House remains an important part of the village’s surviving architectural history; a 1964 newspaper account reproduced by the Village of Rushville describes the building’s association with the Underground Railroad.

The streets of Rushville still connect these stories. Surviving houses, printed accounts and local recollections help us trace the people who offered assistance, the people seeking freedom and the risks they faced.

Joseph Selby and the story of Nelly Gray

One of the best-remembered individuals associated with Rushville’s Underground Railroad history is Joseph Selby, who had escaped enslavement in Kentucky. Accounts preserved by local historians and the Westerville History Museum describe Selby as traveling north in the hope of reaching Canada and eventually securing the freedom of the woman he loved, Nelly Gray, from whom he had been forcibly separated.

Selby arrived in Rushville seriously ill and died before completing his journey. Traditions associate his last days with the Hanby family and the medical care of Dr. Simon Hyde. He is commemorated at Pleasant Hill Cemetery south of the village, alongside other freedom seekers remembered as having died on the route north. The precise circumstances survive mainly through later historical accounts rather than a full contemporary record.

The story left an impression on the young Benjamin Hanby and became closely associated with the subject of his best-known antislavery ballad. The Westerville Public Library’s historical account and the Rushville historical marker dedicated in 2025 both preserve this connection.

A song before the Civil War

Darling Nelly Gray was first published in 1856 by the Boston music publisher Oliver Ditson & Co., five years before the outbreak of the Civil War. Its combination of a memorable sentimental melody with a story of forced separation helped the subject of slavery reach audiences in domestic parlors and public music-making. The song became part of the broader antislavery culture of the 1850s.

The sheet music itself is an important historical object. Its title pages, publisher’s imprints, and later editions show how an individual composition was reproduced, distributed, and remembered. The Ohio History Connection’s study of Civil War-era sheet music places Hanby’s songs within the larger world of nineteenth-century music publishing and political expression.

A remarkably early account of the song’s development appears in Song Writers of Ohio, published in the Ohio Archaeological and Historical Quarterly. It records a recollection by Dr. W. C. Lewis of Rushville, who remembered hearing Hanby read from an early manuscript during the winter of 1855. Such recollections help us understand how the song remained embedded in the village’s memory. Read the historical study.

Another Hanby Song, Still Sung Today

Original illustrated cover of The Dove, an October 1866 number of Our Song Birds edited by George F. Root and Benjamin R. Hanby, owned by the Turner House Collection
The Dove, October 1866, original illustrated wrapper. Turner House Collection.
From the Turner House Collection

Where Up on the Housetop First Appeared

Benjamin Hanby's Christmas song “Santa Claus,” today known as “Up on the Housetop,” first appeared in print in October 1866 in The Dove, the fourth number of Our Song Birds. The illustrated children’s music quarterly was edited by Hanby and George F. Root and published by Root & Cady in Chicago.

The Turner House Collection owns an original 1866 copy of this first publication, with Hanby's song printed under the title “Santa Claus.” Issued only months before Hanby's death in 1867, the book connects Rushville’s native songwriter with one of the most familiar American Christmas songs.

Explore the original 1866 volume

First page of Benjamin R. Hanby's Santa Claus in the original 1866 Dove issue, with illustrated heading, score, and the opening lyrics
The opening of “Santa Claus,” credited B. R. H.
Page 59 of the 1866 Dove songbook, continuing Hanby's Santa Claus with additional stanzas
Continuation of the song on page 59.
Printed music in the Rushville Collection

Hanby in Print

The Collection also preserves later printings of Hanby’s songs and an original illustrated edition of Little Tillie’s Grave. Together they trace how his music passed from Civil War-era audiences into published song anthologies and twentieth-century arrangements.

Original illustrated cover of Minstrel Songs, Old and New, published by Oliver Ditson Company, containing Benjamin Hanby's song Ole Shady
Minstrel Songs, Old and New Boston: Oliver Ditson; edition first published 1882. Includes Hanby’s 1861 song “Ole Shady.”Turner House Collection
Original nineteenth-century illustrated sheet music cover of Little Tillie's Grave by B. R. Hanby, published by John Church Jr. in Cincinnati
Little Tillie’s Grave Cincinnati: John Church Jr., 1860 copyright. A moving example of Hanby’s sentimental songs.Turner House Collection
Darling Nelly Gray musical score arranged by A. La Meda, with printed 1907 copyright at the bottom
Darling Nelly Gray Arranged by A. La Meda; Oliver Ditson Company, copyright 1907. Evidence of the song’s continued circulation.Turner House Collection

The anthology also illuminates a more difficult aspect of nineteenth-century American musical history: antislavery songs could circulate within the racially stereotyped world of commercial minstrelsy. Preserving these original publications allows that history to be studied, not simplified.

From local history to public memory

Rushville continues to mark these histories through memorials and local research. A historical plaque on Main Street commemorates Hanby’s connection to the village and the traditional account of the song’s origins. In 2025, a new Ohio historical marker in the village square highlighted the Underground Railroad, Joseph Selby, and Darling Nelly Gray.

These markers are not substitutes for original documents, but they are valuable evidence of how the community has chosen to remember the past. The Rushville Collection brings together local photographs, books, printed music, and related evidence to investigate those memories and preserve them for future study.

Key moments
1833Benjamin Russell Hanby is born in Rushville.
1840sThe Hanby family and Dr. Simon Hyde are remembered for aiding freedom seekers.
1856Darling Nelly Gray is published.
1861–65The Civil War transforms the national debate over slavery and emancipation.
2025Rushville dedicates an Ohio historical marker recalling this history.

Return to the Rushville Collection

Documentation & further reading

Historical Sources

The surviving sources tell this story in different ways. Published records establish the broader history, while later recollections preserve details of individual journeys and the song’s inspiration that still invite closer investigation.

  1. General Commission on Archives and History, Hanby House, the family’s antislavery activities and historical context.
  2. Westerville Public Library, Slavery & the Underground Railroad, the Selby story and Hanby family.
  3. Song Writers of Ohio, Ohio Archaeological and Historical Quarterly, early reminiscences of Hanby and the song.
  4. Ohio History Connection, The Civil War in Sheet Music, music publishing, abolition, and the Civil War era.
  5. Rushville’s Ohio historical marker, The Underground Railroad in Rushville / Joseph Selby and Darling Nelly Gray (2025), local commemoration.
  6. Visit Fairfield County, Benjamin Hanby Plaque, earlier Rushville commemorative tradition.
  7. Village of Rushville, Dr. Simon Hyde House, transcription of a 1964 local newspaper account.
  8. Westerville Historical Society, Up on the Housetop, publication history of the 1866 first appearance in The Dove.

Contact the Collection with historical evidence or research inquiries