Turner House Collection
Object biography · Painting and printmaking

Saint Agnes

A portrait, a devotional guise, and the circulation of an image through paintings, drawings and prints.

Turner House Collection oil painting of a young woman with a lamb, represented as Saint Agnes
Saint Agnes, oil on canvas, Turner House Collection. Photograph courtesy of the collection.

The story begins with a young woman, a lamb and a portrait that refuses to stay in one form. The Turner House painting belongs to a family of images associated with Sir Godfrey Kneller and Catherine (also spelled Katherine or Katharine) Voss. Its subject is represented in the devotional guise of Saint Agnes, accompanied by a lamb. The relationship between this particular canvas and the wider composition remains under investigation.

Object record

What is established

The painting repeats a composition associated with Kneller. Related evidence includes another painted version, preparatory or related drawings attributed within the Kneller/Byng circle, and mezzotint interpretations. The Turner House canvas has undergone cleaning and relining; comparisons must account for changes in its appearance.

Research status

What remains uncertain

The central questions are now sharper: who painted the Turner House version, how does it relate to the other surviving painting, and what can the drawings and prints tell us about the image’s journey through Kneller’s circle?

Comparative visual study · Four versions

One composition, four interpretations

Select any image to enlarge it; press Escape or use Close to return to the article.

Four side-by-side close views of Saint Agnes: two painted versions followed by two mezzotint interpretations, showing differences in the face, hair and hands
Four-way comparison supplied by the Turner House Collection: the Yale Center for British Art painting; the Turner House Collection painting; and two mezzotint interpretations associated with John Smith and John Bowles (left to right, provisional identification). Comparative montage; individual images are cropped and not shown to scale. Institutional image rights and exact impression details should be confirmed before scholarly republication.

The juxtaposition makes differences in facial modelling, brow line, hairstyle and the position of the hands easier to study. It is a visual comparison, not evidence by itself for a chronological sequence or direct copying relationship.

The image across media

We begin with the details: the sitter’s face and hair, the folds of her dress, the lamb, and above all the hands. A ring visible in some evidence but omitted in later printed representations is one potentially useful detail. Such differences may reflect changes to a plate, the use of different models, or an engraver’s interpretation; they cannot be assigned a single cause without further evidence.

Primary visual references

The composition across media: paintings, drawings, and prints

The images below reproduce the full comparative works rather than repeating cropped views of the Turner House canvas. They should be read alongside the four-way facial comparison above. Reproductions are not standardized for scale, colour, orientation or photographic conditions.

John Smith 1716 Saint Agnes mezzotint showing woman with lamb and book
John Smith's dated mezzotint. John Smith after Sir Godfrey Kneller, Saint Agnes, mezzotint, inscribed 1716. The dated impression provides a firm point in the printed history of the composition.
Reduced John Bowles Saint Agnes mezzotint with inscription Miss Kneller
John Bowles's reduced mezzotint. Miss Kneller in the Character of St Agnes, mezzotint published for John Bowles. The inscription and reduced format are evidence of a later commercial presentation; the exact impression and plate history require further cataloguing.
Yale Saint Agnes painted version with lamb and book
The Yale painted version. Saint Agnes, painted version associated with Sir Godfrey Kneller, Yale Center for British Art. A major comparator for the Turner House canvas; institutional attribution and image-use details should be checked against Yale's current catalogue.
Developed blue-ground drawing of Saint Agnes with lamb
A more developed drawing. Drawing of the Saint Agnes composition associated with the Kneller–Byng circle, reproduced from the research reference image supplied to the Collection. The reversal of the composition relative to some finished images is important when comparing sources.
Rapid red and black chalk sketch of Saint Agnes with lamb
A rapid compositional study. Sketch of the Saint Agnes composition associated with the Kneller–Byng circle, reproduced from the research reference image supplied to the Collection. Its economical marks make the arrangement of hands, lamb, book and background especially instructive.

Source images supplied for research comparison. Attributions and institutional credits are descriptive pending final catalogue verification; no reproduction permission from third-party institutions is implied by their inclusion.

The people behind the image

The research also examines Kneller's studio and its collaborators, including Edward Byng, and the later circulation of portraits through publishers and collectors. Surviving wills, catalogues and print records provide possible pathways for reconstructing these networks, but no unverified ownership chain is presented here as fact.

Questions guiding the investigation

Selected comparative sources

Research materials include the Yale painted version; British Museum drawings associated with the Kneller/Byng circle; John Smith and John Bowles mezzotints; and eighteenth-century print-sale and publisher catalogues. Exact object numbers, impressions and bibliographic references will be added as each comparison is checked for publication.

The investigation continues through close comparison, surviving prints and archival records. Each new piece of evidence helps reconstruct the history of an image that lived far beyond its original canvas.

Return to Selected Objects · Research & Publications